HUMAN BRUCELLOSIS AMONG PYREXIA OF UNKNOWN ORIGIN CASES IN TWO TERTIARY HOSPITALS, IN SANA'A, YEMEN
Ahlam Ali Ahmed Maher1, Belques Sharaf Al-Huraibi1
, Abdulwahab Ismail Mohamed Al-Kholani2
, Omar Abdullah M Al-Dhafari2
, Mohammed Mohammed Ali Al-Najhi3
,
Hassan Abdulwahab Al-Shamahy1,4, Omar Ahmed Esma’il Al-dossary1
,
Azhar Azher Mohammed Al-Ankoshy5
1Medical Microbiology and Clinical Immunology Department, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Sana’a University, Republic of Yemen.
2Department of conservative dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, Sana’a University, Republic of Yemen.
3Department of conservative dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, Genius University for Sciences and Technology, Dhamar city, Republic of Yemen.
4Medical Microbiology department, Faculty of Medicine, Genius University for Sciences & Technology, Dhamar city.
5Jabir Ibn Hayyan Medical University, Faculty of medicine, Department of Physiology, An-Najaf, Iraq.
Background and objectives: Brucellosis continues a most important health problem in numerous parts of the world and in the Middle East regions is a significant origin of acute febrile illness. This study was conducted to determine Brucella antibodies among patients with PUO, the association of brucellosis with demographic characteristics, identify clinical symptoms and risk factors for Brucella infection among PUO cases.
Materials and Methods: This cross-sectional research study was conducted in two health institutions; Al-Jumhouri Hospital and Al-Thawra Hospital, between January 2021 to January 2022. The required data were gathered from each patient by using pre-defined standardized questionnaire. Five mL of sterile whole blood was collected from each patient and then tested for Brucella antibodies using a standard tubular agglutination test. The data were then analyzed using the statistical software Epi Info version 6.
Results: Among the 241 PUO patients, females were 72.2% and males 27.8%. The mean ±SD for total age was 28.8±15.8 years. The rate of Brucella antibody among patients with PUO was 29%, females 78.6% higher than males by 21.4%. Clinical characteristics of PUO patients were persistent fever (36.9%), intermittent fever (63.1%), sweating (63.5%), shivering (61.4%), joint pain (78.4%), muscle pain (78.4%), back pain (74.7) back head pain (66.4%), headache (60.4%), weight loss (52.9%), body weakness (89.2%), loss of appetite (50.6%), and nausea (46.1%). The risk factors for brucellosis among the PUO patients was handling of animals during parturition (69.2%, OR=7, p<0.0001).
Conclusion: These findings revealed a high prevalence of human brucellosis among PUO patients in Sana'a city and will becoming a serious problem that threats the health care system in Yemen. So, awareness programs should be provided to doctors, population about Brucella infection and its risk factors.
Keywords: Brucella antibodies, Brucellosis, Pyrexia of Unknown Origin (PUO), Sana'a City, Yemen.
INTRODUCTION
Human brucellosis is a zoonotic bacterial infection that has been occurred worldwide. Brucellosis is primarily an occupational illness that is infected slaughterhouse workers, veterinarians, farmers, meat inspectors and animal handlers. Brucellosis is caused by several Brucella species belonging to the genus Brucella, which are non-sporous, non-encapsulated, small, Gram-negative bacilli. In the last globally report in 2006, globally each year, more than 500,000 new cases are reported, with annual incidence rates changeable broadly from less than 2 to more than 500/1,000,000 population between diverse regions1. Brucellosis continues endemic in many areas of the world comprising the Middle East, Latin America, the Mediterranean Basin, Africa and Asia1. Global tourists visiting brucellosis endemic areas are at risk of infection. Spread of Brucella to human’s consequences from direct connection with an infected animal, and also from ingestion of unpasteurized milk and dairy products2,3. Brucellosis of human is a lot under-diagnosed or misdiagnosed because the clinical manifestations overlap along with various bacterial infections. High undulant fever, night sweats and weight loss are the most significant indications of human brucellosis. It has been noted that brucellosis is one of the most important causes of long-term fever in endemic areas and one of the important causes of pyrexia of unknown origin (PUO) in endemic areas of brucellosis4,5. In animals, it causes miscarriage, sterility, placenta retention, weak or stillborn calves, and decreased milk production in milk-producing animals5.
Cases of brucellosis are categorized the same as either probable or confirmed cases. A clinically compatible case epidemiologically associated with a confirmed case of brucellosis, or a Brucella agglutination titer equal to or more than 1/160 in one or more serum samples acquired after symptom onset may be determined as a probable case6. Also, laboratory confirmation of a clinically compatible case is judged as confirmed case. On the other hand in endemic countries of brucellosis, clinical symptoms are coupled with seropositive without isolation of Brucella is confirmed human cases6. Human brucellosis laboratory confirmation is based on serological, molecular or/and microbiological methods, and these methods have their disadvantages and advantages. Among the methods used are several serological tests such as Complement Fixation Test (CFT), Rose Bengal Panel Test (RBPT), Coombs Test, Serum Agglutination Test (SAT) and ELISA3-8. By means genus-specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assays, the molecular diagnosis of human brucellosis can be carried out. Molecular assays target the IS711 insertion element and the bcsp31 gene, coding for a 31-kDa immunogenic outer membrane protein conserved among all Brucella spp. are the most common molecular targets in clinical applications9,10. Brucellosis of human is regularly detected by ELISA and agglutination based serological tests, but the gold standard method for diagnosis brucellosis remain isolation of the pathogen from blood by culture4,5,7.
Literature review of infectious diseases in Yemen indicated that the knowledge of brucellosis is still very scanty while more studies were conducted recently in Yemen about viral infections as hepatitis viruses, CMV and Polio virus; leptospirosis, cholera, trachoma, kala-azar, oral infections, eye infections other infectious diseases but no recent studies of brucellosis have been conducted11-32, in conclusion, Yemen has been neglected with regard to the study of brucellosis. This study was conducted to determine Brucella antibodies and associated risk factors among patients with fever of unknown origin (PUO) attending to tertiary hospitals at Sana'a city, Yemen.
SUBJECTS AND METHODS
Study design and study area: This cross-sectional research was carried out in two health establishments; Al-Jumhori Hospital and Al-Thawra Hospital, in Sana'a city, Yemen, during a period of one year starting in January 2021 and ending in January 2022. This study is the second cross-sectional study of Brucella infection among PUO patients in Sana'a city-Yemen in the last 22 years5.
Inclusion criteria: All patients with pyrexia of unknown origin of any age and both gender attending selected hospitals in the period of the study.
Sample size: We selected desired precision of 0.01 (1% acceptable error in the estimation) with possible estimated true proportion of human brucellosis in Al- Dala’a city- Yemen equal to 6.7%33 with Confidence Levels 99% for population of pyrexia of unknown origin in Sana'a city per year equal to 100000, we need at least 241 selected patients with PUO calculated by Using Epi Info version 6 software (CDC, Atlanta, USA) attending in the main hospitals in Sana'a city, Yemen.
Data collection: Data was taken from each patient with PUO by standard predesigned questionnaire designed for this study that includes data as demographic information; name, age, gender and risk factors and clinical symptoms.
Blood sample collection: Five mL of whole blood was collected aseptically by venipuncture from each patient with PUO and serum was separated by centrifugation after clotting. The sera samples were kept at –20°C until tested for Brucella antibodies.
Laboratory test: The sera were tested by standard tube agglutination test using reagent (B. abortus and B. melitensis). Positive and negative control was tested in parallel with tested sera. To avoid laboratory error due to prozone at low titer the final dilution of each serum, positive and negative controls are 1:20 to 1:640 after addition of an equal volume of antigen. Any serum giving a titer of equal or more than 1:640 than a further dilution was carried out. The test was read at 37°C after 24 hours of incubation. A titer of equal to or more than 1:160 were considered positive4.
Statistical analysis: Analysis of data was performed by using Epi Info statistical program version 6 (CDC, Atlanta, USA). The quantitative data was expressed as mean values, Standard deviation (SD), when the data was normally distributed. The qualitative data was expressed as percentages; Chi square test was used for comparison of two variables to determine the p value. Odd ratio (OR) was used with 99% confidence interval. p value <0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Ethical consideration: Consents were taken from all participants and they were informed that participation was voluntary and that they can refuse this without stating any reason.
RESULTS
Out of 241 individuals, the female with PUO 174 (72.2%) of the total, higher than male 67 (27.8%) of all. The mean ±SD of total age was 28.8 years ±15.8 years. The age range of total was one year to 73 years, and the most frequented age was 35 years (mode) (Table 1). Table 2 shows the clinical manifestations of PUO patients; continuous fever occurred in 36.9%, intermittent fever was in 63.1%, sweating in 63.5%, shivering in 61.4%, joints pain in 78.4%, muscle pain in 78.4%, backache in 74.7%, pain head back in 66.4%, headache in 60.4%, weight loss in 52.9%, body weakness in 89.2%, loss of appetite in 50.6% and anorexia in 46.1% of PUO patients. The prevalence rate of brucellosis (≥1/160 SAT) was 70/241 (29.1%), Brucella abortus positive rate was 17%, and Brucella melitensis positive rate was 2.9% and mixed of both
Brucella species 9.1% (Table 3). Table 4 shows that the higher rate of Brucella antibodies were occurred in females (78.6%) with OR equal to 1.6 when compared to males (21.4%) (χ2=1.99, p=0.07). Also, the age group of 16-25 years old had higher rate of Brucella antibodies and there are no statistical significant differences (Table 4).
There was no significant association between residency, occupations, and education with contracting brucellosis among PUO patients (Table 5). The sero-prevalence rate of brucellosis among patients with clinical symptoms was recorded at 33% for intermittent fever, 31.5% for weight loss, 31% for headache, 30.6% for backache, 30.4% for shivering (30.4%), joint pain, 30% for each muscle pain and pain head back, 29.7% for nausea, 28.8% for body weakness, 28.1% for sweating, 27.9% for loss of appetite, and 22.5% for continuous fever patients that summarized in Table 6.
Table 7 shows that the rate of handling animal during birth was 69.2%, with associated risk (OR) equal to 2, with CI=6-17, χ2=22, p<0.0001. The rate of brucellosis among contact animal waste (36%), contact with animal newborn (34.5%), family history of brucellosis (33.3%), farmer (32.1%), ingested raw milk (29.5%), consuming milk products (29.2%), milking animals (28.6%), touch fresh meat (28.1%) and working as microbiologist (23%). There was no significant association between Brucella infection and different animal species (Table 8).
DISCUSSION
Brucellosis continues a most important health crisis in numerous parts of the world and is a significant cause of acute feverish sickness in the regions of Middle East. In spite of this, consistent with the World Health Organization, brucellosis is listed as one of seven neglected zoonotic diseases. Brucellosis is an important cause of PUO in endemic areas34. Estimates of the prevalence of brucellosis among PUO patients are not available for many countries of the world. The low prevalence reported in known brucellosis endemic countries such as Yemen may be due to the absence or low surveillance and reporting systems in these countries, for presence or prevalence of brucellosis5. The prevalence of brucellosis antibodies was 29.1% among the PUO patients in the current study, and this result is almost similar to that reported in Saudi Arabia in old report (23%)35, Ethiopia (31.5%)36, India (22.5%, 29.4%)37,38. In contrast, the current result was higher than that previously reported in Yemen (7.9%)5, Saudi Arabia by Alkahtani recently (12.8%)39, Pakistan (10.1%)40, south western Uganda (14.9%)41, Bangladesh (2.0%)42, and Nigeria (14.9%)43.
In the current study, the percentage of Brucella antibodies among females was 78.6%, while this rate in males was 21.4% lower than in females. Similar results were also recorded in Iraqi females (61.7%), while in males (38.3%)44. In contrast, this result differs with previous studies in Yemen and India where the incidence among males is higher4,38-42. Current data indicate that most females were housewives and exposed to brucellosis risk factors as they directly handled milk or meat or looked after animals44-46. In this study, there is no statistically significant correlation between the presence of antibodies to Brucella disease and the different age groups, as the distribution is almost equal in all age groups (p>0.05).
This is in contrast to the higher risks for the 20th year-old group which were found in Egypt (62%)47, in Ethiopia (48.1%)36, and northern Tanzania (46%)48. Current results indicated that all age groups in the current study are equally exposed to risk factors of brucellosis. In the current study, the prevalence of Brucella antibodies in PUO patients living in rural areas (29%) was almost equal to that in urban areas (28.9%). This result is similar to what was previously found in Yemen3-5,49, Iran50 and Pakistan40. However, this study differed with other study in Egypt by Fouad et al., as 75.5% of their patients were urban residents (p<0.01) 51. It also differs from what Menas et al., and Al et al., in Pakistan52,53, and in Egypt recently47 where most cases of brucellosis were from rural residents. The current study found a significant relationship between brucellosis and handling of the animal during parturition, the rate being 69.2% with a correlation factor equal to 7 (CI=2.6-17, χ2=22, p<0.0001). These findings are similar to previous studies conducted in Yemen5,33, in northern Uganda54, in Pakistan40 and in Nigeria43, where they found that handling animals during childbirth is a risk factor for brucellosis.
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
These findings revealed a high prevalence of human brucellosis among PUO patients in Sana'a city and will becoming a serious problem that threats the health care system in Yemen. So, awareness programs should be provided to doctors, population about Brucella infection and its risk factors. Awareness of brucellosis transmission routes can guide the community and prevent further infection. Further studies of sero-diagnosis and bacterial isolation of the disease, collaboration between researchers and public health professionals in terms of research and expansion of diagnostic services for brucellosis.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors also would like to acknowledge the Microbiology Department of the National Center of Public Health Laboratories (NCPHL) Sana'a, Yemen for support.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
No conflict of interest associated with this work.
AUTHOR’S CONTRIBUTIONS
This research is part of a master's degree in the Department of Medical Microbiology, first author Ahlam Ali Ahmed Maher, who conducted field work in hospitals, and who did laboratory work and other authors contributed to data analysis, drafting and review of the paper, and gave final approval to the research.
REFERENCES