ANTI-DYSLIPIDAEMIA AND CARDIO-PROTECTIVE EFFECTS OF NIGERIAN BITTER HONEY IN STREPTOZOTOCIN INDUCED DIABETIC RATS
Olufunso B. ADEOYE1,2, Abolape A. IYANDA1, Michael O. DANIYAN3, David A. ADEOYE4, Omoyiola L. OLAJIDE2, Omowumi O. AKINNAWO2, Adebola O. ADETUNJI5, Babatunde O. OSUNDINA6, Olajoju M. OLATINWO7
1Department of Chemical Pathology, Faculty of Basic Clinical Sciences, Ladoke Akintola University of Technology (LAUTECH), Ogbomoso, Oyo State, Nigeria.
2Department of Biochemistry, Benjamin Carson School of Basic Medical Sciences, Babcock University, Ogun State, Nigeria.
3Department of Pharmacology, Obafemi Awolowo University (O.A.U), Ile – Ife, Osun State, Nigeria.
4Department of Physiology, Benjamin Carson School of Basic Medical Sciences, Babcock University, Ilisan-Remo, Ogun State.
5Department of Anatomy, Benjamin Carson School of Basic Medical Sciences, Babcock University, Ilisan-Remo, Ogun State.
6Department of Biochemistry, Osun State University, Osogbo, Nigeria.
7Department of Biochemistry, Faculty of Basic Medical Sciences, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria.
Background and Aim: Chronic hyperglycemia, oxidative stress, and dyslipidemia usually predispose to cardiac aberrations. Certain honey samples have been reported to worsen glycemic control or proven to be cardiotoxic. The study sought to elucidate the roles of Nigerian bitter honey in experimental diabetes.
Experimental Procedures: Diabetes was induced in adult female Wistar rats (90–110g) by single administration of streptozotocin (65 mg/kg body weight, i.p.). Rats were randomly allocated into six groups (n=8). Bitter honey (50 mg/kg) and metformin (100 mg/kg) were orally administered daily for 28 days. Animals were sacrificed on day 29 and blood samples were obtained via cardiac puncture. Lipid profile and lipid peroxidation analysis were carried out using standard methods. Atherogenic, coronary, and cardiovascular risk indexes were calculated. Heart, pancreas, and lung tissues were harvested and subjected to histopathological assessment. Data were analyzed using one way ANOVA, and statistical significant level was set at p<0.05.
Result and Discussion: Bitter honey treatment in the diabetic animals significantly reduced hyperglycemia, triglyceride, total cholesterol, low-density lipoprotein, malondialdehyde, and cardiovascular risk levels (p<0.05). Correspondingly, HDL and reduced glutathione levels were significantly higher (p<0.05). Bitter honey preserved the histoarchitectural integrity of the cardiomyocytes and lungs tissue.
Conclusion: The bitter honey is a highly remarkable repository of naturally occurring bioactive compounds that can potentially modulate downstream biochemical pathways of hyperglycemia, dyslipidemia and lipid peroxidation. The bitter honey may therefore be a promising new source of anti-diabetic and cardio protective nutraceuticals.
Keywords: Bitter Honey, cardiovascular risk, diabetes, dyslipidemia, Metformin.
INTRODUCTION
Dyslipidemia is a long-term pathological consequence of type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM) and an inde-pendent risk dynamic of type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM)1. Incidences of TIDM are a function of insulin deficiency, thereby plummeting glucose accessibility and utilization, subjecting the blood to the pathologically relevant pattern of lipid parameters2. Invariably, hyperglycemia-induced dyslipidemia is originated. In contrast, induction of T2DM is preceded by a buildup of circulating free fatty acids to a concentration that is high enough to precipitate insulin insensitivity3. In fact, a high-fat diet has been used to induce experimental models of T2DM, a model of hyperlipidemia-induced hyperglycemia4,. In a recent study conducted in Nigeria, the prevalence of dyslipidemia was found to be 68%5. Progression of dyslipidemia in any type of diabetes mellitus can spawn a chain of redox reactions which may extort endogenous antioxidant defense mechanisms6. Except an ideal intervention is ensured, the structural and functional integrity of the vasculature will always be at risk of oxidative attack from metabolic by-products of lipid peroxidation7. Consequently, progressive oxidative attack to membrane lipid molecules may deteriorate the functional integrity of the endothelial vasculature8. In return, the complex cascade mecha-nism can be an underlying predisposing factor for the development of atherogenic plaques9. Sadly, this can further deteriorate to coronary and cardiovascular complications10.
Natural supplements are well reputed for modulating distinct pathways of disease initiation and progression11. Honey is a natural medium for conserving plant–based bioactive compounds. Distinctively, the sensory properties and medicinal significance of honey varies widely from one geo-botanical origin to the other. Due to the heterogeneity of distinctive bioactive compounds in honey, it therefore represents a grand mix of high profiled phytoconstituents that may potentially interact with multiple indices of disease initiation and progression. Notwithstanding honey is a highly reputed nutritional supplement, especially for its prophylactic and curative efficacy. With adequate knowledge of the indigenous plants constituting its primary geo-botanical source, honey can function to alleviate or modulate many of the symptoms associated with changes in both physiologic and pathologic states12. Therefore, honey can alter the course of various diseases. Depending on the plant basis of its bioactivity, honey supplemen-tation in the diabetic state may likely be a double-edged sword, aside being of no effect at all. For instance, a uniflora bitter (mad) honey from Turkey was reported to be cardiotoxic13,14,15. However, it is not known whether all bitter honeys can predispose to cardiac aberrations irrespective of their botanical source. Also, supplementation with an Egyptian honey has been reported to increase glycosylated hemoglobin among diabetic subjects16. These scientific findings are generating confusions and controversies concerning the suitability of honey as an ideal functional food for diabetics17. Besides, the scientific basis behind the wide variations in the therapeutic value of honey is poorly explored.
In our previous study18, the botanical markers, phytochemical, proximate and elemental compositions of the bitter honey used for this study were reported. Also, the protective effect of the bitter honey on animal models of hepatic and renal damage has been documented19. Meanwhile, some of its plant precursors are reputed as having hypolipidemic and cardio-protective properties. Yet, there is a paucity of data concerning the reproducibility of these nutritional benefits in a bitter honey sample cultivated from those medicinal plants. Therefore, this study sought to explore the roles of a Nigerian bitter honey on indices of hyperglycemia, hyperlipidemia and cardiovascular dysfunctions in animal models of diabetes.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Sourcing of Bitter Honey and other Materials
Bitter Honey (BH) was sourced from Community Lifestyle Improvement Project (CLIP) farm (CRBN: 0953750) into an airtight container. The farm is located at Modakeke (7°27' 19.6704'' North and 4°32' 39.8112'' East) South-Western Nigeria. Prior to use, BH was freshly prepared by diluting with distilled water. Streptozotocin was obtained from Sigma–Aldrich (MO, USA), while other reagents or kits were obtained from Randox laboratory (Aldren, USA) and/or British Drug House (Poole, England).
Animal use and care
Female rats (90–110 g) of Wistar strain were acquired from the animal house of Faculty of Pharmacy, Obafemi Awolowo University (OAU), Ile-Ife. The animals were housed in well-kept and ventilated plastic cages (Mediwise animal cage, 430 × 270 × 15 mm) and a 12-h day/night cycle was maintained. The animals were given standard laboratory pellet (grower’s mash) and water ad libitum. Ethical approval for the study was obtained from Osun State Health Research Ethics Committee (OSHREC) with clearance number OSHREC/PRS/569T/158. All animals were humanely cared for in line with published standard principles of care and use of laboratory animal19.
Induction of Diabetes
Diabetes Mellitus (DM) was induced by a single intraperitoneal (i.p) administration of 65 mg/kg body weight of STZ. Before this, the rats were fasted overnight for about 14 hours. The development of hyperglycemia was confirmed after 72 hrs (using blood obtained from the tail vein). Animals with fasting blood glucose levels ≥ 250 mg/dL were considered diabetic.
Experimental Design
Rats were allocated randomly into treatment groups (n =8) as follows: Group A (non-diabetic control) and group C (diabetic control) were administered 2 mL/kg distilled water daily for 28 days. Group B (non-diabetic BH-supplement) and group D (diabetic BH) were administered 50 mL/kg BH daily for 28 days. To examine BH ability to prevent induction of diabetes, Group E rats were pretreated with 50 ml/kg BH for 28 days, followed by administration of single dose of STZ (65 mg/kg). Group F (diabetic Metformin) rats were administered 100 mg/kg metformin daily for 28 days. All dosage administrations were done orally. A dose of 50 mg/kg body weight of 20% BH was chosen based on the report of Öztaşan et al.,20. Fasting blood glucose (FBG) concentration (mg/dL) was determined at baseline and then weekly (with blood obtained from tail vein) using a portable Accu-Chek glucometer (Roche, Germany).
Sample collection and preparation
Following the last treatment on day 28, rats were fasted overnight (14 hours), and FBG was determined. For the pretreatment group, FBG was also measured weekly until the 28th day and then 72 hours post STZ administration. Rats were the neuthanized under mild diethyl ether in a tightly covered glass jar. Blood samples were collected by cardiac puncture into sample bottles without anticoagulant. The blood samples were allowed to clot at room temperature for about 45 minutes, centrifuged at 1500×g for 10 minutes, and the supernatants (sera) were collected and stored at -200 C until required for analysis. Also, heart, pancreas and lungs were carefully removed, weighed, and preserved in 10% formal saline.
Lipid profile analysis
Triglyceride (TG), total cholesterol (TC), and high-density lipoprotein (HDL) were determined enzymatically using assay kits (Randox laboratory, Aldren, USA) in line with the manufacturer’s protocols. Estimation of LDL (low-density lipoprotein), and VLDL (very-low-density lipoprotein) were conducted using Friedwald equation21.
Estimation of atherogenic, coronary risk, and cardiovascular risk indices
The atherogenic index (AI), coronary risk index (CRI), and cardiovascular risk index (CVRI) were determined using the equations below as earlier described21.
Lipid peroxidation assay
Glutathione (GSH) and malondialdehyde (MDA) were measured by standard methods as earlier described22.
Histopathological analysis
The heart, pancreas and lungs that were fixed in 10% formal saline, were processed routinely for paraffin embedding. Micro sections (5µ) of the tissues were obtained with a rotatory microtome and processed using Haematoxylin and Eosin (H & E) staining technique. Not less than three specimen per sample were processed and slides were viewed under a light microscope, and photomicrographs were taken with a Leica DM750 Camera Microscope (× 400), as earlier described23.
Statistical Analyses
Quantitative data were presented as mean±standard error of mean (SEM) and analyzed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) on GraphPad prism (version 8.0). Post hoc analysis was carried out using Student Neuman–Keuls test and p<0.05 was considered statistically significant.
RESULTS
Effect of Bitter Honey on Blood Glucose
As shown in Table 1, significant differences in FBG levels were observed when the experimental groups were compared (p<0.05). Treatment with 50 mg/kg b.w. of 20% BH significantly lowered blood glucose level (242.83±0.87 mg/dL) when compared with the diabetic control (DC) group (337.08±1.34 mg/dL). Also, FBG was significantly higher in the pre-treatment group (191.3±1.04 mg/dL) relative to the non-diabetic group (62.73±6.13 mg/dL). Meanwhile, metformin (124.2±0.53) treatment also achieved significant reduction in the FBG.
Effect of Bitter Honey on Dyslipidaemia
The effect of bitter honey supplementation on lipid profile parameters are shown in Table 1. Triglyceride level was significantly lower (p<0.05) among the BH supplemented (BH_s), BH treated (BH_t) and BH pre-treated (BH_p) groups relative to the diabetic control (DC) and metformin-treated groups. Total cholesterol was significantly lower (p<0.05) in the bitter honey treated group compared with the diabetic untreated group. High density lipoprotein cholesterol level was significantly higher (p<0.05) in BH treated (BH_t) and BH pre-treated (BH_p) and BH-supplemented (BH_s) groups compared with diabetic control (DC) and metformin treated groups. In addition, LDL-C and VLDL-C were significantly low (p<0.05) in bitter honey treated (BH_t) group relative to both diabetic control (DC) and the metformin-treated groups.
Effect of Bitter Honey on Lipid Peroxidation
Inter-group comparison of concentrations of reduced glutathione (GSH) and malondialdehyde (MDA) revealed significant differences among the various groups. The Diabetic control (DC) group showed significantly lower (p<0.05) concentrations of GSH and a corresponding increase in MDA compared with other groups. Similar to the non–diabetic group, the BH_s, BH_t, BH_p and metformin treated groups had a significantly (p<0.05) increased concentration of GSH and a corresponding low MDA level in relation with the diabetic control (DC) groups.
Effects of bitter honey on cardiovascular, coronary and atherogenic risk Indices
As shown in Figure 1, the diabetic control group presented with significantly elevated cardiovascular risk index (CVRI), coronary risk index (CRI), and atherogenic index (AI).
Whereas, the BH– supplemented (BH_s), BH-treated (BH_t), BH- pretreated (BH_p) and metformin treatment groups had significantly lower (p<0.05) CVRI, CRI and AI relative to the diabetic control (DC) group.
Histological assessment of heart, pancreas and lungs
The diabetic untreated and metformin treated rats had distorted cardiac tissues, unlike the bitter honey treated rat which had a well preserved cardiac histoarchitecture Section shows that the bitter honey treated group (D) had a well-preserved myocardia histoarchitecture similar to the non-diabetic group.
Whereas the diabetic untreated and metformin treated groups had cardiac muscles which presented with mild infiltrations of inflammatory cells (arrow head) as well as perivascular inflammatory cells infiltration (circle) (Figure 2). There was no pathological observation in the lung tissue of all the experimental groups (Figure 3). There was no morphological distinction in the pancreatic tissue sections (Figure 4) of all the experiment animals.
DISCUSSION
Dyslipidemia is a life - threatening metabolic condition with numerous etiologies. Independently, dyslipidemia is often implicated as a key player in several downstream metabolic pathways pertaining to metabolic syndrome. Essentially, dyslipidemia can precipitate progressive redox imbalance and a build - up of atherosclerotic plaques in the endothelial vasculature, thereby eliciting a compromised histoarchitecture of the blood vessels24. Furthermore, dyslipidemia may also impair insulin receptor signaling in such a way as to perturb the cellular uptake of glucose, typical of type II diabetes mellitus25. In the present study, experimental diabetes mellitus was chemically induced by streptozotocin in Wistar rats. To this effect, using standard biochemical and histological methods, a Nigerian bitter honey (BH) variety was screened for its potential pharmacological properties against classic diabetes symptoms viz a viz hypergly-cemia, oxidative stress, and cardiac tissue atheroge-nicity, cardiovascular and coronary indices.
Data obtained from the study showed supplementation with bitter honey among group II animals did not cause a spike in blood glucose level. This suggests an antiglycemic potential of the bitter honey. Meanwhile, treatment of diabetic rats with BH (50 mg/kg BW of 20% BH) for 28 days significantly (p<0.05) reduced blood glucose level. Similar to our findings, certain honey varieties indigenous to forest zones at Oyo26, and Delta27 states of Nigeria were reported to significantly curtail hyperglycemia within three weeks, and eight weeks respectively. In our previous study, we elucidated the botanical characteristics of the bitter honey18. Surprisingly, some of the plant precursors of the bitter honey are reputed for their glucose lowering efficacies in experimental diabetes. Notably, plant precursors such as Elaeis guinensis, Irvingiaga bonensis, Chromolaena odorata may possibly be the hypoglycemic determinants of the bitter honey. In addition, our previous investigation showed that the bitter honey is a potent inhibitor of pancreatic alpha – amylase enzyme28. Distinctively, this suggests that the BH variety is a repository of important bioactive compounds which can potentially modulate specific cellular membrane mechanisms that enhances glucose clearance from the blood. Supposedly, this may include alkaloids, phenolics, terpenes etc. Taken together, these suggests that the normoglycemic property of the bitter honey may have been elicited through multiple dimensions such as the regulation of postprandial hyperglycemia, enhanced facilitated diffusion or improved secondary active transport of glucose into the cell. Contrary to current findings, it is worrisome that certain honey varieties from different plant precursors are reputed for worsening indices of diabetes mellitus. This may be particularly possible if the honey were to be having a high glycemic index. Typically, the outcome of a non – randomized clinical trial involving diabetic volunteers showed that intervention with Egyptian clover honey for 8 weeks and 1 year respectively, resulted in elevated glycosylated hemoglobin16 and worsened dyslipidemia29,. Similar to our findings, certain honey varieties from Indonesia30 and Australia31, could not curtail hyperglycemia following 4 and 5 weeks of treatment respectively. The inconsistent empirical data concerning the anti-diabetic significance of honey can be attributed to the wide variations in the botanical characteristics of each honey variety. The inefficacy of these honey samples to significantly curtail hyperglycemia may likely indicate the absence of bioactive compounds which can potentially modulate downstream biochemical pathways of glucose uptake or utilization. This shows that in as much as their native plant precursors are not the same, the inherent bioactive constituents in a honey sample may likely be quantitatively and qualitatively divergent, hence, a possible variation in their corresponding pharma-cological propensities.
In the present study, STZ administration did not elicit any morphological distortion to the pancreatic islet histoarchitecture. The resultant development of dyslipidemia suggests that a non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus was likely induced by STZ in which case pancreatic β-cell damage was not necessarily implicated. Previous reports on the use of STZ as a diabetogenic agent are quite controversial. Apart from factors such as dosage of STZ, sex32,33, and breed34 of experimental animals, the nutritional status of the experimental animal
have also been implicated as key determinants of the type of diabetes that may be induced by STZ. Importantly, there are increasing empirical data concerning the metabolic roles of dietary fat quality and quantity in STZ induced diabetes36. Under a metabolic condition whereby circulating free fatty acid (FFA) is relatively high in the blood, STZ administration may potentially predispose to insulin resistance37 and consequently hyperglycemia without any adverse effect on the cellular integrity of the pancreatic islets38. Nevertheless, dyslipidemia is a very common feature of STZ induced diabetes. Similar metabolic derangements were reproduced in this study. Abnormal lipid profile parameters were observed among the diabetic untreated rats. In tandem with the observations of some previous authors, BH supplementation normalized dyslipidemia despite not curtailing hyperglycemia. Notwithstanding, an atherogenic index value above 0.24 is strongly associated with an elevated risk of cardiovascular diseases32. Bitter honey supplementation significantly (p<0.05) reduced atherogenic index, coronary and cardiovascular risk indexes. A similar result was obtained for Nigerian honey cultivated at a forest zone in Ebonyi state39. Even when supplemented on a long-term basis, certain honey varieties remained beneficial in the diabetic state. For instance, data obtained in a clinical trial experiment conducted among type 2 diabetic subjects showed that honey supplementation for four months caused a significant reduction of glycated hemoglobin while also curtailing dyslipi-demia40. Also, supplementation with Egyptian clover honey for 6 years was reported to curtail hypertension and stroke despite not ameliorating hyperglycemia and dyslipidemia41.
In our previous study where we characterized the botanical origin of the bitter honey, some of its plant precursors were observed for their roles in modulating molecular pathways of dyslipidemia. These include I. gabonensis42, C. odorata47,48, and B. Sapida46, and some members of the families of Moraceae43, Asteracea44, and Combretaceae45 among others. Infact, there exist a hypolipidemic patent from I. bonensis49. Since the BH was a multi-floral blossom honey, it is therefore possible that the significant hypolipidemic bioactivity of the BH may have been contributed by native plants with such inherent health benefit. The combinations of such plants which constitute the geobotanical origin may therefore likely be the hypolipidemic determinants of the bitter honey.
Diabetes mellitus is an oxidative stress-related disease. Unrestricted lipid peroxidation in the endothelial vasculature can promote life-long pathological consequences on vital organs including the heart, and brain. In this study, lipid peroxidation (LPO) was more pronounced among the diabetic untreated animals, as depicted by a significantly high level of MDA and a corresponding significant (p<0.05) reduction in glutathione (GSH) level. Notably, bitter honey treatment, unlike metformin, significantly (p<0.05) restored the endogenous defense mechanism, GSH, against the deleterious effect of LPO. The prophylactic effect of BH against hyperglycemia-induced peroxidation of lipid molecules was equally significant among the BH pretreatment group. Interestingly, amelioration of hyperglycemia-induced oxidation of LDL has been proposed to be one of the anti - atherosclerotic mechanisms inherent in honey50. The varied antioxidant efficacy of honey owing to its native plant precursors is currently being explored for the management of micro and macrovascular complications diseases. Moreover, the histopathological assessment of cardiac tissues showed that the diabetic untreated group had a distorted cardiac histoarchitecture. A similar degenerative condition of the cardiac tissue was found among the metformin-treated group. However, cardiac tissue integrity was well preserved among the bitter honey-treated diabetic group, but not among the metformin-treated group. This shows that the Nigerian bitter honey used for this study contains essential cardioprotective bioactive compounds which are deficient in the standard drug metformin. The cardio - protective mechanism of the bitter honey may have been elicited by sustaining a metabolic crossfire in resistance to hyperglycemia induced oxidative attack to the endothelial vasculature and cardiac tissue compartments. Interestingly, appreciable and moderate amounts of flavonoid, cardiac glycoside, phenols and steroids have been reported to be present in the bitter honey used for this study18. Consequently, the cardio - protective efficacy may have been elicited by these inherent phytochemicals. Since plant based steroids are known to confer anti inflammation similar to glucocorticoids50, the steroid content of the bitter honey may likely contribute to its anti-inflammatory effects. Moreover, the component sodium and potassium may have also contributed to the cardioprotective property of the bitter honey, as diabetes related hyponatremia51 and hypokalemia52 are widely common.
At the dose administered, the Nigeria bitter honey used for this study did not elicit any form of toxicity to the pancreas, lungs or cardiac tissues. Unlike the uniflora bitter honey native to the black sea region of Turkey, the Nigerian bitter honey indigenous to Modakeke (7° 27' 19.6704'' North and 4°32' 39.8112'' East) is not mad. Unfortunately, the expression of cardiotoxic grayanotoxin in Turkish bitter honey is a distinguishing feature that is peculiar to its rhododendron plant source. By implication, none of the indigenous plant constituting the botanical origin our bitter honeyis likely to be a repository cardio toxic-grayanotoxin. This shows that the variation in the botanical origin of any honey is a key determinant of its nutrient quality and quantity, as well as its corresponding therapeutic significance. Notably, the cardioprotective property of our bitter honey unlike Turkish bitter honey affirms that honeys from different floral origin are not exactly alike in terms of bioactive mechanisms and corresponding pharmacological significance. Due to the indigenous plant source of their bioactive markers, each honey sample is biochemically and therapeu-tically distinct. However, this suggests that the potential pharmacological value of a particular honey sample may be exclusively homologous to the vegetal basis of its bioactive mechanisms. This will clarify the controversy concerning the conflicting pharmaco-logical potentials of honey, especially with respect to its antidiabetic properties.
Limitations of the study
This is animal experimentation and should be further investigated before direct applications to human beings. Also, limited resources prevent our desire to unravel the mechanism(s) of the reported activities at cellular and molecular levels.
CONCLUSION
Data obtained from this study suggest that the botanical source of the bitter honey may likely have been dominated by native plants which synthesize a relatively higher amount of hypoglycemic, hypolipidemic or cardioprotective bioactive compounds. These properties suggest that the BH used for this study in combination with standard hypoglycemic agents may likely produce better treatment outcomes in the management of dyslipidemia, diabetes and associated vascular complications. Further study is needed to evaluate the long term effects of the bitter honey treatment at varying doses, and also to profile the actual bioactive compounds eliciting the therapeutic response.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Authors are thankful for the Obafemi Awolowo University, Osun State, Nigeria to provide necessary facilities for this work.
AUTHOR’S CONTRIBUTION
OBA, AAI, and MOD: Conceptualization and Project Administration. MOD and AAI: Validation, Method development, and Resource sourcing. OBA, DAA, OLO, OOA, AOA, BOO, and OMO: Performed the experiments. OBA, AAI, OLO, OOA, OMO, and MOD: Data analysis. OBA: Write initial draft of the manuscript. OBA, DAA, OLO, OOA, AOA, BOO, OMO, AAI, and MOD: Reviewed and edited the manuscript, and approved the final submission.
FUNDING
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The Authors declare no conflict of interest
REFERENCES